Gardening Alternatives to Pesticides

Facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedinmail

By Steven Spence
@TheStevenSpence

Gardens are a delight

Sadly, it’s not just gardeners, bees, butterflies, and birds that enjoy gardens. Gardens inevitably also attract insect pests, as I know firsthand from working on my little plot with flowers and fruit trees. In my first year of gardening, I didn’t know what to do to get rid of an aphid infestation, so I went to a local garden supply store and was advised to buy some spray-on pesticides, which I reluctantly used. After that experience, I began to talk with other gardeners and read about alternatives to pesticides. Since then I’ve controlled insect pests in my garden through natural methods because I want our apples and cherries to be pesticide-free, which is also quite good for the bees and butterflies that visit.

Defenses and countermeasures

In dealing with a pest invasion, there are multiple alternatives to pesticides available to gardeners. Here are four methods that provide gardeners with a broad set of tools.

  1. Companion planting: planting certain types of plants will keep some pests away.
  2. “Soft” chemicals: soap, stinging nettles, and rhubarbs provide excellent alternatives to pesticides.
  3. Parasites: certain pests are often easily targeted by specific parasites.
  4. Predators: ladybird beetles and birds will decimate many pest infestations in short order.
Companion planting
Gardening Alternatives to Pesticides
Lavender is a bee-friendly companion plant.

The idea behind companion planting is to deter insects by strategically placing plants known to repel certain types of pests. Companion planting is sustainable and, in some cases, can even improve the soil through nitrogen fixation. Here are a few examples of companion planting.

  • Allium species (such as onions, chives, garlic, leeks, and shallots) are great to plant around vegetables (including tomatoes, potatoes, cabbage, broccoli, and carrots) and roses. They help repel aphids, slugs, carrot flies, Japanese beetles, and cabbage worms.
  • Petunias repel aphids, tomato hornworms, leafhoppers, and squash bugs.
  • Lavender repels moths and their caterpillars, fleas, flies, and mosquitoes. It is excellent on garden paths or near entryways.
“Soft” chemicals
An adult Adalia bipunctata, or ladybird beetle, looking for lunch.

Commonly used insecticides contain pyrethroids (synthetic versions of pyrethrin, a chemical found in chrysanthemums) or neonicotinoids (similar to nicotine). Consumers may not know they are using a neonicotinoid, as the active ingredient may have a dissimilar name (for example, the most commonly used neonicotinoid is imidacloprid).

Both pyrethroids and neonicotinoids have raised concerns about their impact on beneficial insects such as bees. Softer, safer alternatives can often be used, avoiding side effects on groundwater and beneficial insects.

  • Soaps, diluted to less than 2 percent, can be used in gardens. Household soaps will often suffice, but some sensitive plants such as cherry trees and sweet peas may find household soaps too harsh. Garden centers often have a suitable soap spray for these plants.
  • Plant oils, although not viable on a commercial scale, applied in a small residential garden can be effective against pests. Examples of such oils include rosemary, eucalyptus, geranium, thyme, lavender, and lemongrass.

Sometimes no chemical is needed at all. Physically brushing away caterpillar nets or washing pests off plants with a stream of water may do the trick.

Parasites

One of the benefits of applying or attracting parasites is that parasites generally target host insects specifically. Here are examples of parasites at work.

  • Gardening Alternatives to Pesticides
    A root-feeding grub from the Scarabaeidae family.
      • Nosema locustae is a fungal spore typically attached to wheat bran for dispersion. When this parasite is attached, grasshoppers consume less wheat bran and eventually die.
      • Wasps are natural parasites of many common insect infestations. They lay their eggs in pests, and the wasp larvae consume the hosts. They are effective against a wide range of pests including aphids, scale, whiteflies, and some caterpillars.
      • Nematodes are a type of unsegmented roundworm. Beneficial nematodes can be used against a wide variety of insect pests, including grubs and insects in their larval stages. Japanese beetles and lawn grubs are just two examples of insects controlled by beneficial nematodes.
Predators

This is one of my preferred methods of pest control. Ladybird beetles, birds, and frogs are fantastic allies in battling garden pests.

Gardening Alternatives to Pesticides.
A ladybird beetle larvae hunting for aphids.
  • Ladybird larvae are voracious and will decimate aphid infestations quickly. The adults are also good at eating aphids but only consume approximately one-third as much as they do during their larval stage.
    • Frogs and toads eat slugs, snails, and some insect pests.
    • Lacewings are excellent at eating aphids, blackflies, and whiteflies.
    • Birds are great predators of insect pests. Blackbirds and various tits are common visitors to my garden and eat a wide variety of insects, especially caterpillars and sometimes grubs. I have observed firsthand that birds are excellent at keeping pests out of my fruit trees. (The blackbirds consume some of my cherries each year, but I let it happen as there is enough for all of us. Nets are effective protection when the cherries are ripening.)
Gardening Alternatives to Pesticides
Aphids being tended by ants.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Gardening Alternatives to Pesticides
Pesticide-free apples ripen in the author’s garden. Blackbirds and tits frequently visit and consume pests.

Steven contributes photography and general science articles to GotScience. Steven has a small garden, which he keeps pest-free with ladybirds, lavender, and sometimes soap. He is an avid fan of dinosaurs, raptors, and Calvin and Hobbes.

All photos by the author.

Additional information

Companion Planting:

http://www.agriculture.vsu.edu/files/docs/cooperative-extension/companion-planting-in-gardening.pdf

http://pemaruccicenter.rutgers.edu/assets/PDF/publications/2013-InTech-Companion_planting_and_insect_pest_control.pdf

Pyrethroids:

https://www.epa.gov/ingredients-used-pesticide-products/pyrethrins-and-pyrethroids

Parasites of Garden Insect Pests:

http://ipm.ucanr.edu/QT/parasitesinsectcard.html

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/gardening/problem-solving/why-you-should-use-nematodes-as-pest-control/

Great Tits Reduce Caterpillar Damage in Apple Orchards:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1784073/

Biological Control and Natural Enemies of Invertebrates:

http://ipm.ucanr.edu/PMG/PESTNOTES/pn74140.html

Bee Precaution Pesticide Ratings:

http://www2.ipm.ucanr.edu/beeprecaution/

GotScience Magazine, published by the nonprofit Science Connected, is made possible by donations from readers like you. With your help, we create equal access to science literacy and education. Click to learn more about Science Connected and get involved.

Facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedinmail